Thanksgiving 2020

Published: November 21, 2020

Bishop Anthony B. Taylor preached the following homily during a Mass with his family on Thursday, Nov. 26, 2020.

Bishop Taylor

No one immigrates because things were going so great in the Old Country. All our immigrant ancestors had problems in their country of origin: for instance, one of our grandfather Emil Roth’s relatives told me that his parents came here due to anti-Semitic persecution. They had endured threats in what is now Poland for some time, but around 1887 they were burned out in a pogrom — an anti-Jewish riot — which was the last straw.

Rather than rebuild, they pooled their money and sent three of the men to New York including our great-grandfather Louis Roth. They worked and earned enough to bring our great-grandmother Jenny and their two oldest children over starting in 1888.

Our grandmother Ceil’s parents, Josef Fichtner and Josefa Meindl, immigrated from Bavaria due to poverty and also because they had a big problem: they had a baby on the way but couldn’t get married because Josef was from across the border in what is now the Czech Republic and had been working in Germany without legal status — he was a citizen of Austria-Hungary.

They got married on Ellis Island. But even here they faced challenges due to their foreign ways and accented English, especially when the U.S. went to war with Germany in World War I. We descend from people who were marginalized in their country of origin, and though things were better here, life was still hard for them. And the same is true for immigrants who come here fleeing violence and poverty today.

In today's Gospel Jesus encounters 10 men who were marginalized, in their case by leprosy, a horrible disease that people feared — worse than the threat of COVID-19. Most people do recover medically from the coronavirus, so the COVID quarantine is for 14 days. Leprosy, on the other hand, was chronic and at that time medically incurable, so outside of a miracle, people with leprosy were quarantined for the rest of their lives.

And so, by healing them, Jesus not only cures their disease with a miracle, he also ends their quarantine — that's why he tells them to go get a clean bill of health from the priests. In this way they could return home and resume a normal life. He redeems these 10 men, who otherwise would have remained marginalized by disease. But only one, a Samaritan, a man doubly marginalized by ethnicity and disease, returned to give thanks to Jesus.

On Thanksgiving we give thanks to Jesus for his many blessings, including thanks for bringing our ancestors to this land of hope to give us a better future. Can you imagine what our life would be like if they had remained in Europe? Our family lost many relatives on our mother’s side of the family in the Holocaust — including 20 first cousins and their children who died at the extermination camp at Belzec.

Only two of Emil’s first cousins are known to have survived the war — they had been sent to Auschwitz. If our great-grandparents had stayed behind, we would probably not exist. The fact that as an adult Emil had converted to Catholicism would not have made a difference to Hitler.

But the earthly redemption which we celebrate today is nothing compared to the eternal redemption we celebrate in the Eucharist, the very name of which, "Eucharist," is Greek for "thanksgiving". But you know, the Samaritan leper in today’s Gospel wasn't grateful to Jesus just that one day. He was grateful all the rest of his life, the same as our immigrant ancestors and today's immigrants who are so grateful to God for their new American homeland, the blessings of which we so often take for granted.

But we should feel even more grateful to Jesus for redeeming us from the spiritual leprosy of sin. The Eucharist is our sacrament of thanksgiving. We gather around this altar of hope and join our grateful hearts to the loving heart of Jesus as he continues to offer himself in total sacrifice for us, who otherwise would not have a good eternal future.